Elon Emails

'Doing the right thing': don't be a jerk, accept apologies

From:
Elon Musk
Date:
May 31, 2017
To:
All Tesla employees
Subject:
Doing the right thing

Partial text. Only these passages were published; [...] marks a gap.

Part of not being a huge jerk is considering how someone might feel who is part of an historically less represented group. This doesn't mean there is a different standard of performance or that you can't give critical feedback. You should -- doing anything else would be an insult to the hard work it took to get there -- but don't ever intentionally allow someone to feel excluded, uncomfortable or unfairly treated. Sometimes these things happen unintentionally, in which case you should apologize. In fairness, if someone is a jerk to you, but sincerely apologies, it is important to be thick-skinned and accept that apology. If you are part of a less represented group, you don't get a free pass on being a jerk yourself. We have had a few cases at Tesla where someone in a less represented group was actually given a job or promoted over more qualified highly represented candidates and then decided to sue Tesla for millions of dollars because they felt they weren't promoted enough. That obviously is not cool.

About this email

In a company-wide email on workplace conduct, Musk says employees must consider how members of historically less represented groups feel, should apologize for unintended offence and accept sincere apologies, and that minority employees get no free pass; he complains some have sued Tesla after being promoted. A racial-harassment suit quoted it and Tesla then released it in full.

Notes

First quoted in the Vaughn v. Tesla class-action complaint (Alameda County, Nov 2017); Tesla then published the whole email in its 14 Nov 2017 blog post 'Hotbed of Misinformation', which is no longer on tesla.com. Fortune and Teslarati reproduce the full email only as an image that could not be read in this session, so the text here is the contiguous passage printed by Bloomberg (two consecutive quotations; paragraph break is Bloomberg's). 'apologies' is as printed by Bloomberg; Jalopnik prints 'apologizes' and '[a] historically'. The opening and close of the email are missing. The safety email Musk sent the same day ('No words can express how much I care about your safety...') may be the first part of this same message; that could not be confirmed.

Where it came from

Court record; attribution confirmed.

Tesla, company-wide memo. Tags: harassment, culture, discrimination, lawsuit, conduct