Elon Emails

First Falcon 1 launch attempt scrubbed over LOX and helium loss

From:
Elon Musk
Date:
November 26, 2005 (NASA Watch gives the time of the statement as November 26, 2005 at 5:11 p.m. PST.)
To:
SpaceX update mailing list
The launch is scrubbed for today. As I warned, the likelihood of an all new rocket launching from an all new launch pad on its first attempt is low. What happened was that an auxiliary liquid oxygen (LOX) fill tank had a manual vent valve incorrectly set to vent. The time it took to correct the problem resulted in significant LOX boiloff and loss of helium, and it was the latter that caused the launch abort. LOX is used to chill the helium bottles, so we lose helium if there is no LOX to cool the bottles. Although we were eventually able to refill the vehicle LOX tanks, the rate at which we could add helium was slower than the rate at which LOX was boiling away. There was no way to close the gap, so the launch had to be called off. In addition, we experienced an anomaly with the main engine computer that requires further investigation and was arguably reason in and of itself to postpone launch. We are anticipating rescheduling the launch within a week at the earliest but probably longer as we need to bring in LOX and helium from Hawaii. Our LOX plant on Omelek will not replenish in time.

About this email

Musk's note after the first Falcon 1 countdown was called off. A manual vent valve on a ground liquid oxygen tank was left open; fixing it cost so much LOX and helium that the launch had to be abandoned, and an engine computer anomaly also needs investigating.

Notes

NASA Watch introduces it as 'According to Elon Musk at SpaceX: on November 26, 2005 at 5:11 p.m. PST'. Kimbal Musk's blog quotes the two middle paragraphs as 'the summary of the cause of the abort from Elon', with a different closing sentence ('The next launch attempt is expected to occur in approximately mid-December, depending on the time required to resupply LOX and helium.'), which suggests the posted text was revised. A missing space in the reader output ('Omelekwill') was restored. SpaceRef's copy ('SpaceX Falcon 1 Launch Scrubbed') now returns HTTP 410. Text was retrieved through a page reader, so punctuation and paragraph breaks may differ slightly from the original page.

Where it came from

Published by Musk; attribution widely reported.

SpaceX, newsletter. Tags: spacex-update, falcon-1, kwajalein, launch-scrub, maiden-flight